The Location of Your Franchise is Important — Remember to Protect it

 In Business Law

Location, location, location. That is what we always hear when it comes to buying a house or setting up a business. For a franchisee, the decision of where to set up your operation is a crucial part of determining your likelihood of success. However, in addition to choosing the right location, protecting it against various issues and liabilities involving competitors is often overlooked.

The location of your franchise is important — remember to protect it to safeguard yourself into the future. Here are some simple ways to do this.

Negotiate Restrictions in Your Lease

You just opened up your new store and business is going well. Then, within the same complex, a new store opens up selling the exact same product or service as you, taking away a good amount of your customers. How could you have prevented this from happening? By negotiating an exclusive right in your lease to be the only store in the shopping centre to sell that product or service. This would mean that, in the future, if a competitor were to approach your landlord about opening a location in the same shopping centre, the landlord would have to turn that potential tenant away for fear of breaching the terms of your lease.

The idea of protecting your location was recently featured on CTV. In this case, Pita Pit had entered into a lease that gave them the exclusive right to sell pitas and wraps in a specific shopping plaza. Subsequent to signing the lease, the landlord entered into a lease for a different unit in the plaza with Holy Guacamole, which sells burritos. Pita Pit brought a claim arguing that the lease with Holy Guacamole violated their exclusive right to be the only tenant to sell wraps and pitas in the complex since a burrito was, in essence, a wrap. The judge in the case found in favour of Pita Pit and granted an injunction, which prevented Holy Guacamole from opening its location. Now, protecting your location this way may not be as effective if you are in a small complex or if there are other shopping centres nearby with different landlords (so they would not be bound by the agreement you signed with your landlord). However, if you are in a large big box complex or shopping mall, this could be an important step in ensuring the long-term success of your franchise.

Negotiate an Exclusive Territory in Your Franchise Agreement

You have been operating your location for quite some time and things are going well as always. You have spent a lot of time and money marketing your business and built up a lot of goodwill for your franchise’s brand since you opened your doors. Then, you notice just down the road that your franchise is opening a new location which will take away a good amount of your business. You are surprised since you never expected to have to compete with your own franchise and wonder “how could this happen”? In a franchise agreement, there are often provisions outlining the area you have been given for the franchise. For example, the franchise agreement may say you have exclusive right to “Ottawa East” (and define what that means) or say that no other franchise can be opened within a two-kilometre radius of your location. However, if there is no exclusive area given to you, the risk of another store opening near your location is a problem, so negotiating some type of exclusive area into your franchise agreement is a good idea. In the event the franchisor will not agree to an exclusive area, you can at least try to get a right of first refusal in the franchise agreement for any new locations opening in a certain area. That way, if the franchise wishes to open a new location in the vicinity of your store, they would have to approach you first before seeking out other franchisees.

Obviously, there are numerous other factors that will impact the success of a business. The location of your franchise is important — remember to protect it. Remember this when negotiating the terms of your lease and franchise agreement.

This blog post was written by Jason Peyman, a member of the Business Law and  Real Estate teams.  He can be reached at 613-369-0376  or at jason.peyman@mannlawyers.com.

 

Recommended Posts

Leave a Comment

Start typing and press Enter to search