Offices in Ottawa and Perth
(613) 722-1500

CONTACT US (613) 722-1500

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin

Passage of Time and Parenting Arrangements: What Constitutes a Material Change in Circumstances?

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Passage of Time and Parenting Arrangements: What Constitutes a Material Change in Circumstances?

By:

Posted February 20, 2019

If you have young children at the time of separation, the idea of a Court Order being “Final” is something of a misnomer, specifically as it relates to parenting.  As children develop and their needs and circumstances change, parenting arrangements may need to be adjusted.  This raises the question of whether the passage of time alone will give rise to a material change in circumstances, allowing for an application to vary to proceed.  The answer to that question is “it depends.”

There are cases that fall on both sides of this issue.  In a decision by the Manitoba Court of Appeal, Elliot v. Loewen 1993 CarswellMan 36, the court upheld a decision by the lower court which found that the needs of a three year old child were different from those of an eighteen month old child.  At the time of the original order, the father had been granted supervised access.  By the time the child was three, there was evidence before the court that the father had regularly exercised access and that he had made genuine efforts to develop a meaningful relationship with the child.  The Court of Appeal stated that the motions judge was entitled to take judicial notice of the fact that the needs of a three year old in relation to his father are different than the needs of an eighteen month old child.

This decision can be contrasted with that of the decision of the Court of Appeal in Saskatchewan in Wiegers v. Gray 47R.F.L. (6th) in which the court stated,

It is my view that mere passage of time and increased maturity of the child does not, in and of itself, constitute a material change of circumstances as required by s. 17(5) of the Divorce Act and the case law that has interpreted that section. Were it otherwise, there would be an automatic right to seek variation of custody orders on a regular basis every few years. This is clearly contrary to the established law. While the reviewing judge may, of course, take into account that a child’s needs may change as he or she matures, it is necessary to go further to determine whether and to what extent those changes have, in the case before the reviewing judge, made the original order inadequate.

The decision in Wiegers v. Gray was recently cited in the decision of Coppin v. Arboine 2018 CarswellOnt 19895.  Relying on the decision in Wiegers, the court found that there was no material change in circumstance, despite the fact that the child was two years old at the time of the previous order and was now four years old and the father had limited parenting time.

One thing is certain; these cases can be difficult and emotional for all involved.  No matter which side of the argument you wish to take, a careful review of the case law in this area is required.

This blog post was written by Kate Wright, a member of the Family Law, Wills and Estates and Litigation teams.  She can be reached at 613-369-0383 or at kate.wright@mannlawyers.com.

More Resources

Blog |
Business Law

By: 

Posted October 20, 2021

On October 19, 2021, the new Ontario Business Registry System launched. This new online registry now enables businesses and not-for-profit corporations to directly access services[...]
Blog |
Environmental Law

By: 

Posted October 14, 2021

In the decision of Greenpeace Canada (2471256 Canada Inc. v. Ontario (Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks), 2021 ONSC 4521, released September 3, 2021,[...]
Blog |
Employment, Labour, and Human Rights

By: 

Posted October 1, 2021

This blog continues our exploration of the potential employment law consequences stemming from the degree of control a party exerts within a variety of business[...]
Blog |
Personal Injury

By: 

Posted September 27, 2021

Personal Injury lawyers and their clients are all too familiar with the carnage and suffering caused by impaired drivers.  Canada has the worst rate of[...]
Blog |
Bankruptcy and Insolvency, Business Law

By: 

Posted September 24, 2021

As is noted by the Court of Appeal in McEwen (Re), released August 12, 2021, referred to here as “Traders”, the BIA is a complete[...]
Blog |
Wills, Trusts and Estates

By: 

Posted September 23, 2021

In-Trust For Accounts have become a common way for parents and grandparents to set aside money to finance their children or grandchildren’s post-secondary education. A[...]

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Name*
Consent*
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.