Offices in Ottawa and Perth
(613) 722-1500

CONTACT US (613) 722-1500

Is there Personal Liability for Infecting Someone with Coronavirus?

Is there Personal Liability for Infecting Someone with Coronavirus?

By:

Posted April 3, 2020

As the Coronavirus (COVID-19) spreads across Canada, new legal questions about this lethal illness are going to arise. For example, what happens if a person knows that they have COVID-19 and fails to take the necessary precautions, with the result that they spread the infection and infect others? Can they be sued by the people they infect?

The most likely legal cause of action in these circumstances would be negligence. The four requirements to establish negligence are:

1. A duty owed by the defendant to the plaintiff;

2. A breach of that duty;

3. Damages (illness) experienced by the plaintiff; and

4. Causation of those damages by the defendant.

The breach of duty requirement is often most difficult to establish in a negligence claim. However, that element would appear to be obvious if a person knew that they had COVID-19, ignored advice to isolate themselves, and endangered others. The biggest challenge in such a case would likely be proving that their actions were the cause of the other person’s illness.

It is likely that a person who contracts COVID-19 through community spread will not be able to identify the person they contracted the virus from. However, if they could, they may succeed in a negligence claim if:

1. They became ill – mere exposure to the virus would not be sufficient;

2. The source of the virus knew, or should have known, that they were contagious; and

3. The source of the virus was careless in not staying home.

There would likely be several “causation” hurdles in bringing a successful case even in these circumstances.

1. The potential delay between exposure and the onset of illness;

2. The likelihood that the plaintiff was out in the community and therefore exposed to potential COVID-19 carriers on more than one occasion;

3. The possibility that the plaintiff was exposed to the virus from undiagnosed but contagious carriers. This is a more recent discovery about COVID-19.

These difficulties may be less challenging if several people who attended the same place contracted the virus and had little other potential exposure to it. However, even in these circumstances, establishing “causation” would not be certain.

Perhaps some lessons can be learned from prior litigation arising from claims based on the transmission of HIV/AIDS and other sexually transmitted infections. Several such lawsuits were brought in the 1990’s and early 2000’s. When plaintiffs in these lawsuits lost, it was often because causation was hard to prove.

Conclusion

We have seen on the news that not all Canadians are following instructions from the various levels of government to stay home unless there is a legitimate pressing need to go out, such as grocery shopping. Anyone experiencing symptoms that could be an indication of COVID-19, a cough or fever, have been instructed to self-isolate and not leave their house unless it is to get medical attention. As community spread continues across the country, we are seeing cases of people with symptoms ignoring this directive.

Anyone who can establish that, on a balance of probabilities (greater than 50%), they contracted COVID-19 from someone who ventured out into the public when they knew, or should have known, that they presented a COVID-19 threat to others, may be able to sue them for damages.

This blog post was written by Edward (Ted) Masters, a member of the Disability Insurance Claims and Personal Injury teams.  He can be reached at 613-566-2064 or at ted.masters@mannlawyers.com.

More Resources

Blog |
Wills, Trusts and Estates

By: 

Posted May 17, 2022

I am often asked the question of whether the will-maker should disclose the contents of their will to their beneficiaries.  In some situations, the will-maker[...]
Blog |
Real Estate

By: 

Posted May 10, 2022

The More Homes for Everyone Act, 2022 (“Bill 109”) received Royal Assent on April 14th, 2022. Some sections of Bill 109 will come “into force”[...]
Blog |
Real Estate, Wills, Trusts and Estates

By: 

Posted May 3, 2022

As we all know, house prices are skyrocketing in the region, and this in turn has resulted in parents providing assistance to children who are[...]
Blog |
Employment, Labour, and Human Rights

By: 

Posted April 26, 2022

The mediator’s reaction to my client’s disclosure that she had secretly recorded her conversation with her boss was one of dismay.   He made it clear[...]
Blog |
Family Law

By: 

Posted April 25, 2022

Family law litigation can be a particularly complicated and expensive legal endeavor exacerbated by the emotional difficulties of a fractured relationship. These matters become even[...]
Blog |
Real Estate

By: 

Posted April 14, 2022

What is the Federal Budget? Every year the Department of Finance is tasked with balancing the revenue and expenses of the Government of Canada. As[...]

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Name*
Consent*
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.