Insurers – Bad Faith Negotiating

Insurers – Bad Faith Negotiating

By:

Mann Lawyers

Posted March 9, 2015

Many people don’t know this, but insurers are required by law to attempt to settle a motor vehicle accident claim as quickly as possible. If they drag their feet, play hardball, negotiate in bad faith or refuse to consider reasonable settlement offers then this behavior will be considered by the court when it comes time to make an award of costs in the litigation.

As a general rule, successful parties are entitled to an award of costs.  In the recent Ontario case of Maxwell v. Luck, the trial judge ruled that the insurance company breached its statutory duty to attempt to settle the claim expeditiously.  He ordered that the insurer pay the plaintiff’s legal costs of the litigation in the amount of $206,000.00 together with the further sum of $50,000.00 that he described as a ‘remedial penalty’ that was assessed against the insurance company owing to its breach of statutory duty.

More Resources

Blog |
Wills, Trusts and Estates, Estate Litigation
By: 

Posted July 10, 2025

When Mrs. Crumb became estranged from two of her four children, she reportedly cut them out of her Will. However, she had already designated all[...]
Blog |
Real Estate
By: 
If you’re a first-time home buyer in Canada, navigating rising prices and high interest rates can feel overwhelming. That said, there is some good news.[...]
Blog |
Family Law
By: 

Posted June 24, 2025

When a marriage or common law relationship breaks down, parents must determine how they will make decisions for their children (joint or sole decision-making) and[...]
Blog |
Estate Litigation
By: 
June 15 marks World Elder Abuse Awareness Day, a time to raise awareness about the prevalence of elder abuse, and remind and empower everyone to[...]
Blog |
Estate Litigation, Wills, Trusts and Estates
By: 
When Mr. D’Onofrio died at the age of 43, he left behind a common law partner, an ex-wife and three children. He also left behind[...]
Blog |
Environmental Law
By: 
In our previous blog, “Canada’s Final State of PFAS Report Reveals 100+ Federal Contaminated Sites—Is Your Property at Risk?”, we reviewed the federal government’s March[...]