Offices in Ottawa and Perth
(613) 722-1500

CONTACT US (613) 722-1500

No Appeal to be Taken Concerning Wind Energy Project

No Appeal to be Taken Concerning Wind Energy Project

By:

Mann Lawyers

Posted June 30, 2020

In an earlier blog post, I discussed the decision of the Divisional Court in Nation Rise Wind Farm Limited Partnership v. Minister of the Environment, Conservation and Parks, 2020 ONSC 2984, a decision which overturned the decision of the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks to cancel regulatory approval of a wind energy project in the Township of North Stormont.

Although it was reported at the time of release of the decision that the Concerned Citizens of North Stormont (CCNS), who had challenged the initial approval of the project, were considering an appeal of the decision, the group has since decided not to appeal.  The Minister has also chosen not to appeal.

As a result, the decision of the Divisional Court will stand, and the project will be allowed to proceed.

The decision is important as it emphasizes that those who are granted statutory power to make decisions must make those decisions within the scope of authority granted by the statute.  In this case, the Minister considered issues which had not been argued on the appeal.  The Divisional Court found that under the provisions of the Environmental Protection Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.17, the Minister was only granted the authority to “revoke, vary or affirm the decision, in the public interest, in respect of a matter in appeal”.

The Court was clear that an administrative body cannot exercise authority which was not delegated to it.  The Minister was restricted to making a decision on the issues raised in the appeal.

In the background of the Minister’s decision, which was found by the Divisional Court to be unreasonable and not deserving of deference, it must be recalled that the provincial Progressive Conservative Party was implementing policies based on its election platform which advocated for the cancellation of all wind projects in the province.  It has been reported that the government has spent approximately $231 million since being elected on the cancellation of over 750 renewable energy contracts.

The Divisional Court’s decision illustrates what can occur when a Ministerial authority is charged with rendering a decision in a matter which is subject to political pressures.  In deciding the merits of an appeal on the basis of an issue not even before him, the motives of the Minister are subject to question.  In this case, the Divisional Court’s intervention has provided the necessary checks and balances to prevent the Minister from exercising his power outside of the scope of his statutory authority.

This blog post was written by Cheryl Gerhardt McLuckie, a member of the Environmental Law team.  Cheryl can be reached at 613-369-0365 or at cheryl.mcluckie@mannlawyers.com.

More Resources

Blog |
Family Law
By: 
Co-parenting with your ex-partner can be challenging. It involves constant coordination and communication about various aspects of your children’s lives. Whether it is about schedules,[...]
Blog |
Wills, Trusts and Estates
By: 
Over time, individuals could acquire assets in different jurisdictions that are governed by different legal systems. Similar to the consideration of double wills in distinguishing[...]
Blog |
Family Law
By: 

Posted January 31, 2024

In the first part of this series, we reviewed the background, trial, and appeal to the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal in Anderson v Anderson. This[...]
Blog |
Practice Management
By: 

Posted January 26, 2024

On July 17, 1797, ten lawyers were present at the Wilson’s Hotel in Newark, Upper Canada, to read “An Act for the better regulating the[...]
Blog |
Business Law
By: 

Posted January 23, 2024

A not-for-profit corporation incorporated pursuant to the Canada Not-for-Profit Corporations Act (the “CNCA”) is required to maintain certain records, including records as to its members,[...]
Blog |
Employment, Labour, and Human Rights
By: 

Posted January 17, 2024

In November of 2023, the Ontario government introduced new legislation, once again, amending the Employment Standards Act, strengthening employment and labour laws in the province.[...]
Cheryl Gerhardt McLuckie

Cheryl Gerhardt McLuckie

I practice in the areas of environment law and commercial litigation and am an active member of the environmental law group at Mann Lawyers LLP. Prior to joining Mann Lawyers in June of 2020, I practiced with a small law firm in Ottawa.  When the opportunity arose to join Mann Lawyers and become part of its exceptional team, I welcomed it.  Being part of a firm that offers a broad range of services will be of great value to my clients. In my environmental law practice, I assist my clients with all manner of issues arising from environmental contamination.   I have extensive experience in land contamination issues, an area which has undergone significant evolution in recent years.  I provide clients with a wide range of services in environmental law including litigation of environmental claims, defending environmental claims, advising on environmental risk, obligations and liabilities, engaging with the Ministry of the... Read More

Read More About Cheryl Gerhardt McLuckie

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Consent*
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.